The short answer
For most travellers from North America, the Dominican Republic (Punta Cana), Mexico’s Caribbean coast (Cancún) and Jamaica are the cheapest places in the Caribbean for a beach holiday. All three have a lot of flights and a lot of competing all-inclusive resorts, which keeps prices down. Puerto Rico is often good value from the US because it is a domestic flight. Aruba, Barbados, Saint Lucia, Turks and Caicos and the Cayman Islands usually cost more.
Updated 17 November 2026
What makes a Caribbean island cheap
Two things decide most of the price: the flight and the hotel. Islands with many flights from big airports have more competition on fares, and islands with many large resorts have more competition on rooms. That is why Punta Cana, Cancún and Montego Bay, each with a busy international airport and dozens of all-inclusive resorts, are usually cheaper than smaller islands with a few flights a week.
All-inclusive resorts can also make a trip cheaper overall even when the room rate looks higher, because meals and drinks are already paid for. On islands where you eat out every night, food can cost as much as the room.
The usual cheapest choices
Dominican Republic (Punta Cana)
The largest number of all-inclusive resorts in the Caribbean and a very busy airport (PUJ), so it is often the cheapest all-inclusive beach trip from the US and Canada.
Punta Cana packages →Mexico (Cancún and the Riviera Maya)
Short flights from much of the US, a huge choice of resorts at every price, and cheap day trips to cenotes and Mayan ruins.
Cancún flight + hotel packages →Jamaica
Many flights into Montego Bay (MBJ) and a wide range of resorts, from big all-inclusives to small guesthouses in Negril. Eating at local spots off the resort is good value.
Jamaica packages →Puerto Rico
For US travellers the flight is domestic, so no passport is needed, and there are many flights to San Juan (SJU). Hotels are mostly city and beach hotels rather than all-inclusives.
Puerto Rico packages →Colombia (Cartagena)
Hotels, food and tours in Cartagena usually cost less than on most islands, although flights can cost more from some cities.
Cartagena packages →
Usually more expensive
Aruba, Barbados, Saint Lucia, Antigua, Turks and Caicos and the Cayman Islands tend to have higher hotel prices and fewer flights. The Bahamas is a short flight from Florida, but hotel rates in Nassau and on Paradise Island are often higher than in Punta Cana or Cancún. These islands can still be good value in the low season or with a member rate, so compare your own dates.
How to make any Caribbean trip cheaper
Avoid the peak weeks
Christmas, New Year, Presidents’ Day, spring break and Easter are the most expensive. Late April to early June and September to early December usually cost least.
Fly mid-week
Tuesday, Wednesday and Saturday departures are often cheaper than Friday and Sunday.
Try nearby airports
Fares can differ a lot between airports a short drive apart, such as Fort Lauderdale and Miami, or Hamilton and Toronto.
Book flight + hotel together
A package is often cheaper than the same flight and hotel booked separately, and each package shows its price for your dates so you can compare.
Cheap Caribbean packages right now →Check the hurricane-season terms
The cheapest months overlap with the hurricane season (1 June to 30 November). Pick a refundable rate or travel insurance if you travel then.
Cheapest live package to each destination
The lowest member price we have for each destination right now, for the dates, nights and airport shown. Lengths of stay differ, so open a package to price your own dates.
Flight + hotel packages

San Juan · Flight + hotel
Hampton Inn & Suites San Juan
5 nights + flights MIA → SJU · Dec 17 – Dec 22 · 2 adults
Breakfast Included
View package$1,555$1,512
total · members save $43

Cartagena · Flight + hotel
Hotel Almirante Cartagena Colombia
5 nights + flights MIA → CTG · Dec 17 – Dec 22 · 2 adults
Room Only
View package$1,786$1,767
total · members save $19

Montego Bay · Flight + hotel
Verney House Resort
5 nights + flights MIA → MBJ · Dec 17 – Dec 22 · 2 adults
Room Only
View package$1,941$1,929
total · members save $12

Punta Cana · Flight + hotel
Occidental Caribe - All Inclusive
5 nights + flights MIA → PUJ · Dec 17 – Dec 22 · 2 adults
Room Only
View package$1,996$1,959
total · members save $37

Nassau · Flight + hotel
Courtyard by Marriott Nassau Downtown/Junkanoo Beach
5 nights + flights MIA → NAS · Dec 17 – Dec 22 · 2 adults
Room Only
View package$2,137$2,093
total · members save $44

Aruba · Flight + hotel
Eagle Aruba Resort
5 nights + flights MIA → AUA · Dec 17 – Dec 22 · 2 adults
Room Only
View package$2,581$2,523
total · members save $58

Cancún · Flight + hotel
Presidente InterContinental Cancun Resort by IHG
5 nights + flights MIA → CUN · Dec 17 – Dec 22 · 2 adults
Room Only
View package$2,685$2,640
total · members save $45

Barbados · Flight + hotel
Radisson Aquatica Resort Barbados
5 nights + flights MIA → BGI · Dec 17 – Dec 22 · 2 adults
Room Only
View package$2,815$2,778
total · members save $37
Frequently asked questions
What is the cheapest Caribbean island to visit?
From the US and Canada, the Dominican Republic (Punta Cana) is usually the cheapest for an all-inclusive beach trip, followed closely by Cancún in Mexico and Jamaica. Prices change by date and departure airport, so compare live prices for your own dates.
What is the cheapest month to go to the Caribbean?
September and October are usually the cheapest, followed by late April to early June and November. They fall in or near the hurricane season, so choose flexible rates. Mid-December to April is the most expensive.
Is all-inclusive cheaper in the Caribbean?
Often, yes, once meals and drinks are counted, especially on islands where restaurants are expensive. If you plan to eat out and explore a lot, a room-only or breakfast rate can work out cheaper.
Which Caribbean island is cheapest from the UK?
Jamaica, the Dominican Republic, Barbados and Antigua have the most flights from the UK, mainly from London Gatwick and Heathrow. Fares change a lot by date, so compare your dates on the flight search.

